New Delhi: Lok Sabha Monday witnessed a heated face-off between Chief of the Opposition Rahul Gandhi and the treasury benches when he tried to learn out excerpts on the 2020 China border disaster from former Military chief M.M. Naravane’s unpublished memoir, inviting repeated objections from Speaker Om Birla, Defence Minister Rajnath Singh and House Minister Amit Shah.

Birla’s refusal to permit Rahul to cite from an unpublished e-book, triggered an uproar, resulting in a number of adjournments of the Home and eventual washout of the proceedings.

The excerpts have been in regards to the decision-making course of across the Rechin La tensions between India and China and the usage of tank columns.  By the way, ThePrint was first to report the complete particulars of the operation that was described as a “race for the passes”.

Rahul was interrupted by the defence minister moments after he started his speech on the Movement of Thanks on the President’s deal with. The Congress MP mentioned that whereas he had no intention of elevating the problem in his speech, BJP MP Tejasvi Surya compelled him to take action by questioning the Congress’s patriotism and understanding of Indian tradition.

“A younger colleague over there made an allegation in opposition to the Congress get together. I used to be not going to boost this situation, however as a result of he has raised the problem about our patriotism, our understanding of Indian tradition, I wish to begin by studying one thing. And that is from the memoir of Military Chief Naravane. I would really like you to hear properly, you’ll perceive precisely who’s patriotic and who just isn’t,” Rahul mentioned.

“That is about when 4 Chinese language tanks have been coming into Indian territory. They have been taking a ridge in Doklam, and the military chief writes, and I quote from an article that’s quoting his e-book. The tanks have been inside a couple of hundred metres of the Indian place within the Kailash vary,” he continued, prompting the defence minister to rise and object.

“Has the e-book been revealed wherein he has talked about this stuff? If it has been revealed, then you definitely point out it. But when it has not been revealed, then it’s not acceptable to say it,” Singh mentioned. Rahul asserted that the e-book is “one hundred pc genuine” and that Singh was “getting exercised as his title goes to be talked about”.

Singh retorted, “I simply need him to answer whether or not the e-book has been revealed or not. If not, then he ought to make clear which e-book he’s quoting from.” Rahul then held up a replica of the journal that revealed the excerpts, prompting the house minister to step in.

In October 2025, responding to a query on the pending approval from the federal government on the publication of his memoir—‘4 Stars of Future’—Naravane had mentioned that the writer had submitted it to the Ministry of Defence for overview.

“So it’s not for me to observe up. The ball is within the writer’s and the MoD’s court docket. However I loved writing the e-book, for higher or for worse. And that’s that. It’s for the MoD to provide permission as and after they deem match,” he mentioned. 

The December 2023 PTI information report incorporates Naravane’s account of the tense scenario that developed following the motion of 4 Chinese language tanks alongside the Line of Precise Management in japanese Ladakh on the evening of 31 August, 2020. 

In his unpublished account, Naravane additionally detailed the measures, together with his interactions with the political management, which he took to cease the Chinese language tanks from coming into Indian territory and forestall any additional escalation. 

“{A magazine} can write something,” Shah mentioned, difficult Rahul to authenticate his claims. Rahul responded by reiterating that the excerpts are “assured genuine”, including that “Common Naravane has mentioned that the federal government just isn’t permitting it to be revealed”. 

At this level, Birla intervened and mentioned that an MP can’t learn out the contents of a e-book on the ground of the Home even when it has been revealed.

As Rahul refused to budge from his place, his microphone was reduce off. 

SP chief Akhilesh Yadav defended Rahul, saying, “The matter of China could be very severe. If there may be any suggestion within the nationwide curiosity, then I imagine that the LoP ought to learn it. Dr Ram Manohar Lohia, George Fernandes and Netaji (Mulayam Singh Yadav) all the time used to say that we must always all the time be cautious of China.”

When the Home reconvened at 4 pm, BJP MP Jagdambika Pal assumed the function of the presiding officer. Prime Minister Narendra Modi and House Minister Shah had additionally left the Home. The defence minister remained current.

“There’s a essential matter I’ve been attempting to boost. It’s a matter of nationwide safety. I don’t perceive what’s there in these phrases that the PM and Amit Shah have escaped,” Rahul mentioned, mentioning the absence of Modi and Shah from the treasury benches. 

Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju took exception to the usage of the phrase “escaped”.

 Ultimately, at 4.10 pm, the Home was adjourned for the day.

(Edited by Ajeet Tiwari)

---

Additionally Learn: Military chief lambasts Chinese language infra push in Shaksgam Valley. ‘We think about it unlawful motion’

---