AAP provides tadka to Akali atta-dal populist recipe with rebrand, new substances. ‘However the place’s the cash’

AAP provides tadka to Akali atta-dal populist recipe with rebrand, new substances. ‘However the place’s the cash’

Last Updated: February 28, 2026By

Chandigarh: Nearly 20 years in the past, the Shiromani Akali Dal-Bharatiya Janata Social gathering (BJP) and the Badals rode to energy in Punjab on the again of a populist ‘atta dal’ scheme. Now, Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann is hoping somewhat added ‘tadka‘ to the tried-and-tested populist recipe can have an analogous impression on the Aam Aadmi Social gathering’s (AAP) political fortunes in subsequent yr’s Meeting polls.

These kits will probably be distributed quarterly—usually in April, June, October and December—and are supposed to enhance the dietary consumption of economically weaker households, particularly youngsters, who’ve been discovered to undergo from undernutrition.

“The Meri Rasoi scheme builds on current wheat distribution underneath the PMGKAY by including protein within the type of dal, cooking necessities and condiments, thereby broadening the meals help package deal,” stated a senior meals and civil provides division official.

The federal government has earmarked practically Rs 1,000 crore for the programme’s rollout, with Markfed (Punjab State Cooperative Provide and Advertising Federation) because the nodal company for equipment preparation and the Division of Meals and Civil Provides chargeable for distribution and high quality management.

Aside from the annual invoice of Rs 2,600 crore paid by the Authorities of India (GoI) for wheat being distributed quarterly underneath the PMGKAY initiative, the ‘Meri Rasoi’ scheme will value the cash-strapped state authorities one other Rs 1,000 crore, overlaying procurement, packaging and distribution.

The AAP authorities says this will probably be budgeted within the 2026-27 estimate with provisions for high quality assurance and provide continuity.

Over practically twenty years, the Punjab authorities’s Atta Dal scheme has advanced by way of a number of redesigns, finally merging with nationwide food-security entitlements. The atta element of the scheme has really been wheat, whereas dal was distributed intermittently until 2017, after which it was utterly stopped.

The monetary burden of the scheme on the state authorities eased after it was merged with the Central authorities’s Nationwide Meals Safety Act in 2013, which offered subsidised grain to the poor. In 2020, it was determined to supply beneficiaries underneath the Act grain freed from value underneath the PMGKAY.

Thus, the scheme’s core goal of offering subsidised grain to the poor regularly advanced into giving grain freed from value.

‘Aggressive populism is ruining Punjab’

Specialists say that the Punjab authorities, with a debt burden of Rs 4.17 lakh crore, may not have the ability to reconcile its beneficiant freebie guarantees with its constrained finances. If the federal government fails to execute the scheme within the yr main as much as elections, it might show extra dangerous than helpful.

Ranjit Singh Ghumman of Amritsar’s Guru Nanak Dev College, a famend monetary skilled on Punjab, instructed ThePrint that such populist measures have been aimed in direction of electoral features and led to no financial growth of the state.

“Such measures level in direction of the shortage of political will to sort out core points like employment and rural infrastructure,” stated Ghumman.

He added that if the expenditure on such schemes have been diverted in direction of meals processing by Markfed, it might result in the agricultural educated youth getting employment. “As a substitute, Markfed has now been saddled with this work.”

Ghumman stated that he was not in opposition to subsidies however in opposition to subsidies being given throughout the board.

“Subsidies must be focused and graded in accordance with the paying capability of the beneficiary. The one issues free that the federal government must be specializing in are high quality training and well being; as an alternative, the main target is on giving free meals and energy even to those that don’t want it.”

He stated that freebies have been, in a manner, a “bribe” to voters, particularly after they have been rolled out earlier than polls. “This unfounded race of aggressive political populism won’t ever finish as soon as a profit is given; it’s virtually not possible for any subsequent authorities to withdraw it.”

“Additionally it is part of a deeper design, a progress paradigm, a worldwide mannequin that’s based mostly on not producing employment, the place the core message is that even when you don’t do any work, we is not going to allow you to die,” stated Ghumman.

Main Punjab economist Sucha Singh Gill, who headed the economics division at Punjabi College in Patiala, instructed ThePrint that the fiscal scenario of Punjab was “extraordinarily grim” and bulletins of freebies and doles have been solely worsening the scenario.

“The newest announcement of the Punjab authorities has been impressed by the election leads to Bihar, the place the BJP gained arms down largely because of freebies,” stated Gill.

“The Punjab authorities is already massively in debt and must take extra loans to meet its populist guarantees. Nearly 30 % of Punjab’s total finances is used to service loans. It’s a debt lure that may solely result in social chaos. And we’re already seeing the primary indicators of it with growing violence stemming out of rampant unemployment.”

Gill added that the GoI had misplaced its ethical authority to test states as a result of it was itself so massively in debt. “The Authorities of India wants to steer by instance.” .

Pramod Kumar, who heads the Institute of Improvement and Communication in Chandigarh, stated that the conversion of freebies into votes doesn’t essentially have a direct connection.

“Elements like belief and beliefs, other than doles, have an equal function to play as a way to have an electoral impression. It’s by no means one factor; it’s a bouquet of things,” he stated.


Additionally Learn: Ink, gin & a ‘witch hunt’: Inside Mann govt’s synchronised blitz on Punjab Kesari


‘Govt ought to reclaim growth agenda’

Famend economist Lakhwinder Singh Gill, professor on the Thapar College of Liberal Arts and Sciences in Patiala, stated that liberalisation had led to the privatisation of the event agenda, leaving the federal government with little stake in growth actions.

“For the reason that state has no agenda to spend money on financial exercise and growth, it creates a vacuum to showcase politically. And if political leaders should win votes, they should take pleasure in giving out freebies and doles since they don’t have another,” stated Gill.

“The one resolution is for the federal government to reclaim the event agenda and public coverage. In any other case, as a way to stay in political energy, the one manner votes will probably be sought is by increasing the welfare system by way of doles.”

Naresh Singla, an affiliate professor at Central College of Punjab in Bathinda, instructed ThePrint that freebies are provided primarily for electoral features quite than as a part of long-term structural coverage.

“Freebies provide prompt reduction by growing disposable earnings of susceptible sections. This additionally boosts native financial actions, notably throughout financial slowdowns. Consequently, freebies act as social security nets and help inclusive progress,” he stated.

Singla added that very often, extreme and poorly designed measures enhance income expenditure, worsen fiscal deficits and public money owed, and find yourself crowding out productive capital investments within the financial system, which impedes long-term progress prospects.

“Aggressive populism amongst political events additional erodes fiscal self-discipline. Freebies are essential for financial resilience within the preliminary phases of growth. However these must be regularly translated into productive capital investments to make sure fiscal sustainability and promote long-term growth.”

He added that Punjab’s financial system continues to face excessive income deficits, rising public debt, and shrinking capital expenditure.

“A shift from consumption-heavy populism to productivity-linked funding is the important thing determinant for restoring fiscal well being whereas safeguarding social welfare. Boosting rural earnings by way of farm diversification to livestock and allied agricultural enterprises and rural industrialisation is important for the state’s financial system,” he stated.

“Lastly, strengthening social governance and social compliance of the establishments is crucial for a multiplier and long-term impression on the event of Punjab’s financial system.”

Previous experiments met with restricted success

Within the 2007 Atta-Dal scheme, virtually 13.5 lakh Under Poverty Line (BPL) beneficiaries acquired closely subsidised wheat and pulses. Wheat was offered at Rs 4 per kilogram and pulses at Rs 20 per kilogram each month, with an higher restrict set at 25 kg monthly.

By September 2009, Punjab’s coffers have been struggling to fulfill the monetary commitments of the scheme and dal distribution grew to become intermittent.

The enactment of the NFSA in 2013 by the GoI entitled eligible residents to subsidised meals grains by way of the Focused Public Distribution System (TPDS), mandating 5 kg of grain per individual monthly at subsidised charges to “precedence households”. There isn’t any higher cap for this scheme.

The earnings standards for eligibility for the scheme have modified through the years and are set by the state governments.

Cardholders of the previous atta dal scheme have been included within the GoI scheme for the distribution of wheat, and the variety of beneficiary households went as much as over 36 lakh by the tip of 2017. Dal continued to be distributed by the SAD-BJP authorities, although intermittently.

In 2017, when the Congress authorities got here to energy underneath Amarinder Singh, Punjab introduced that the brand new atta dal scheme would proceed, however solely after biometric verification.

A authorities white paper on state funds that yr stated that to fulfill the price of implementing the atta dal scheme, the SAD-BJP authorities organized funds from the State Procuring Businesses (SPAs).

These businesses diverted funds from the credit score money restrict secured from the GoI for the annual procurement of wheat and paddy. Unpaid liabilities of Rs 1,747 crore have been nonetheless excellent as on 31 March 2017, added the white paper.

The white paper additional famous that from 2012 to 2017, dal had solely been provided for 16 months. The then Punjab authorities continued with the scheme funded by the GoI however discontinued the distribution of dal altogether.

In 2020, following the Covid outbreak, the beneficiaries underneath the Nationwide Meals Safety Act (NFSA) have been made a part of the PMGKAY and even the subsidised value of grain was accomplished away with.

When the AAP occasion got here to energy in 2022, its white paper on state funds stated that the unpaid pending liabilities of state procurement businesses of Rs 1,747 crore since 2017 had elevated to Rs 2,274 crore in 2021-22.

It additionally undertook a verification drive of beneficiaries in 2024, with the opposition alleging that over 11 lakh beneficiaries had been excluded. The AAP authorities additionally experimented with giving flour as an alternative of wheat, however was unsuccessful and reverted to giving wheat.

The PMGKAY beneficiaries embrace virtually 40 lakh cardholders, who, other than receiving wheat, will now obtain dal and different condiments from the Punjab authorities.




Source link

Leave A Comment

you might also like