Thiruvananthapuram: Practically six years, a number of court docket dates and a protracted political battle later, the CMRL-Exalogic case, allegedly involving fraudulent funds to a agency owned by Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan’s daughter Veena T., got here to a standstill when the Kerala Excessive Court docket stayed additional proceedings in April.

Nevertheless, the matter continues to be a political scorching potato with the opposition United Democratic Entrance (UDF) repeatedly alleging that the crawling probe displays an alleged nexus between the ruling Left Democratic Entrance (LDF) and the BJP-led Centre, and the state BJP in flip alleging that LDF is making an attempt to stall the probe till after meeting elections subsequent yr.

The case got here to the fore in 2019 with an Earnings Tax Division search at CMRL’s premises. The Kerala Excessive Court docket’s establishment order this April got here quickly after the Ernakulam Periods Court docket took cognisance of the SFIO cost sheet.

Nevertheless, the Excessive Court docket and the Supreme Court docket proceed to obtain a number of petitions looking for a Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) probe. Two excessive court docket division benches have recused themselves from listening to the petitions.

Congress MLA and KPCC functionary Mathew Kuzhalnadan, who approached each courts looking for a CBI probe, mentioned the response from the judiciary was disappointing. “The Earnings Tax Division is a central authorities company. It’s the IT physique’s report that mentioned the case must be probed beneath the Prevention of Corruption Act. When there may be an official assertion from a physique like that, why is there no suo motu case by the ED or CBI?”

Kuzhalnadan mentioned he’s ready to see the SFIO probe in addition to the end result of a pending PIL looking for a CBI investigation to determine his subsequent plan of action. “I attempted my greatest, but when the entire system doesn’t really feel such issues want correction, I can’t take it alone. I don’t have private vengeance,” he mentioned.

In the meantime, the state BJP has denied the UDF’s prices of an LDF-Centre nexus. Shone George, the state BJP chief who approached the court docket looking for a CBI probe in September, mentioned neither he nor the BJP needs to take up the problem politically and make allegations within the run-up to polls, and solely plan to take it legally.

“The BJP by no means requested me to not take up the case. However the celebration or the central authorities just isn’t taking any quick choices like the way it occurred for Kejriwal. We solely need to transfer legally with out involving politics in it,” he mentioned.

He added that the chief minister and the state authorities have been halting central authorities initiatives and that the Congress’s allegation is baseless.

George additional mentioned that the SFIO report states there have been unlawful transactions, which is able to solely grow to be clearer if the CBI conducts a probe based mostly on the report. He mentioned the BJP-led central authorities is supporting him within the case.

ThePrint reached a number of CPI(M) leaders, who refused to touch upon the matter. ThePrint additionally contacted Senior Advocate Vijay Bhanu, who represented CMRL and Exalogic within the excessive court docket, who mentioned he had forgotten the small print. In April this yr, each Pinarayi in addition to CPI(M) state secretary M.V. Govindan had mentioned the probe was a political conspiracy. The Kerala CM had additionally mentioned that the transactions between the companies have been authorized and taxes have been paid.

---

Additionally Learn: Political worth of a Communist CM’s daughter marrying a Muslim — Priceless for India’s Proper

---

The case

The case goes again to 2019, when an IT Division raid discovered that CMRL had allegedly bribed many politicians within the state and inflated its expenditure.

The raid revealed that the corporate, the one listed agency in India manufacturing artificial rutile, had entered right into a contract with Bengaluru-based Exalogic Options in 2017. It confirmed that the corporate allegedly continued to make funds with out specifying any companies.

Later in 2023, the New Delhi bench of the Earnings Tax Interim Settlement Board issued an order stating that no software program help or companies have been being rendered by Exalogic Options and that the transactions between the 2 companies have been unlawful.

By the tip of the yr, many PILs have been filed within the Kerala Excessive Court docket looking for a CBI probe. In January final yr, the Union Ministry of Company Affairs ordered a six-member SFIO investigation.

Although Exalogic, CMRL and Kerala State Industrial Growth Company (KSIDC) challenged the probe within the Kerala Excessive Court docket, their plea was dismissed. Across the similar time, Exalogic Options moved the Karnataka Excessive Court docket to stall the probe.

In April this yr, the Ernakulam Extra Periods Court docket took cognisance of the SFIO report. The court docket discovered prima facie offences within the SFIO’s prices and mentioned there was sufficient floor to situation summons to all 11 accused, together with Veena T.

In keeping with the chargesheet abstract filed by the SFIO, accessed by ThePrint, the probe discovered fraudulent funds of Rs 2.7 crore benefitting Veena and Exalogic.

Expenses have been invoked beneath the Firms Act, 2013, together with Part 447 coping with fraud, Part 448 (false statements), and Sections 129 and 134 (violations associated to monetary statements and the board’s report).

Nevertheless, the Kerala Excessive Court docket, that very same month, directed a two-month establishment on a plea filed by CMRL difficult the periods court docket’s resolution to take cognisance with out a pre-cognisance listening to. The keep, initially ordered for 2 months, was prolonged for 4 months on 23 September.

The excessive court docket in March dismissed a petition by the Congress’s Muvattupuzha MLA, looking for a probe towards Pinarayi in reference to the case.

Equally, the BJP’s Shone George approached the Kerala Excessive Court docket looking for SFIO complaints however failed. Journalist M.R. Ajayan additionally approached the excessive court docket looking for a CBI probe, with two benches earlier recusing themselves from listening to it.

(Edited by Sugita Katyal)

---

Additionally Learn: Polls on horizon, Pinarayi govt makes large strikes—hikes in pension & ASHA employees’ honorarium, new schemes

---